Gefilte Fish, Mimi's Grandmother's - pareve

Posted by : Mimi Hiller

I wrote an article about my grandmother's gefilte fish that was published
in the LA Times a few years ago. My cousin wrote to ask me for the recipe,
and here is what I wrote him (unedited):

You need 4 kinds of need carp, whitefish, pike and another kind
of your choosing. It must be kosher, of course, but look for a fairly firm
fish like the above. Russ Parsons changed my article to say halibut, but
that's gross. Do NOT use's too firm and makes the fish hard and
dry. Bubbe used mullet, but sometimes you can't get that. She never swore
by the above and always told me not to buy fish if it was expensive, but
she almost always bought carp, whitefish, pike and mullet in all the years
I helped her make it (and she helped me, in the last few years of her life).

Carp is a no less than have them clean it for you...filleting it
is the biggest royal pain I've ever experienced in my kitchen. I can buy it
in a place that will fillet it, but I have to pay about $4 a pound for that
privilege (though there are times it's worth it)...on the other hand, if I
pace myself, I can buy all the fish and fillet it myself and save a bundle.
There are places in LA and the valley where I can get carp for .79 or .99 a
pound...they'll clean it for that price but I can't even pay them to fillet
it. Anyway, unless you have fillets in hand, allow yourself a lot of time
to take care of this.

Here are the proportions I recommend...these are approximate, so nothing is
engraved in stone:

4 pounds of carp fillets 2 pounds each of whitefish, pike and mullet fillets

Anyway, you need not only the fillets, but all the crap that goes with
them, too...heads, tails, bones, skin...the works.

And lastly, when I was learning how to make it from Bubbe, she taught me to
taste the raw fish mixture to determine if it was seasoned properly. Those
days are past. What with all the bacteria in animal products, you don't
want to do that you cook small amounts to taste and adjust
seasonings. It takes a lot longer this way, but you're guaranteed to make
it to the seder in good health.

Fish heads, tails, skin and bones saved from the fillets
8 ribs of celery, cut into 3-inch pieces
10 pounds fish fillets, ground (if the fishmonger fillets it, get
       him to grind it for you, too)
2 large sweet onions, chopped
1/2 cup sugar
1 teaspoon finely ground black pepper (I also use coarsely ground)
8 large eggs
2 cups matzo meal
1 pound carrots, peeled and sliced
Freshly ground black pepper
DIRECTIONS: Cut 2 pieces of cheesecloth large enough to hold fish heads,
tails, skin and bones. Place in cheesecloth and tie closed. Put cheesecloth
packets in 2 large pots and cover with water. Add 1 to 2 teaspoons salt and
half of celery and bring to boil. Turn heat down, cover and simmer 2 hours.

If fish has not been ground at market, grind fish in meat grinder or in
small batches in food processor.

Place ground fish in large bowl. Add onions, sugar, 2 T. salt, 1 teaspoon
finely ground black pepper and stir to combine. Lightly beat eggs and blend
with fish mixture. Mix in matzo meal, 1/2 cup at a time until mixture is
almost consistency of light meatballs, adding more if necessary. (If
mixture becomes too hard, add a little water.)

Place fish mixture in refrigerator to allow flavors to blend while fish
stock is simmering.

When stock is finished, remove cheesecloth packets, allowing packets to
drain back into pot. Discard these packets and their contents. Transfer
about 2 cups of fish stock to small pot and bring to simmer.

Wet hands and form a small ball with about 1 tablespoon of the fish
mixture. Place in pot, cover and cook about 10 minutes. Allow to cool 1
minute, then taste. Adjust seasonings to taste. Gefilte fish should be
slightly spongy with sweet and lightly peppery taste.

When seasonings are adjusted properly, with wet hands form about 1/2 cup
fish mixture into slightly elongated shape. Lower fish ball into simmering
stock. Repeat with remaining mixture, dividing between 2 pots. If
necessary, add water to stock. Spread 1/2 carrots and 1/2 remaining celery
over fish. Sprinkle with paprika and pepper. Repeat in second pot with
remaining carrots, celery, paprika and pepper.

Bring both pots to boil. Reduce heat and simmer, covered, 30 minutes.
Remove from heat without lifting lids. Allow to stand, covered, another 30

Serve warm or cold with warm fish stock and horseradish. Separate fish from
stock before refrigerating. Gefilte fish may be reheated in stock. Makes 40
gefilte fish balls.

Return to RFCJ Archive Page